| 1989 |
Allison Townley '83 |
Olympic Rower |
| 1990 |
Joe Murphy '48 |
Mountain Climbing |
| 1991 |
Jim Finch '72 |
Wheelchair Athlete |
| 1992 |
Muffy Ritz '75 |
Cross-Country Skiing |
| 1993 |
John Burton '40 |
Runner, Life-long Athlete |
| 1994 |
Carolyn Leavenworth '78 |
Karate/Rowing |
| 1995 |
David Nash '63 |
Tennis |
| 1996 |
Charlie Briggs '80 |
Professional Rodeo Cowboy |
| 1997 |
Betsy Aldrich '85 |
Hockey/Golf |
| 1998 |
Alex Bernstein '93 |
NFL Football Player |
| 1999 |
Lila Andrews Gidlow '58 |
Alpine Ski Racer |
| 2001 |
Amy Randall '88 |
Champion Fly Fisher |
| 2002 |
Angus "Sandy" Morrison '70 |
Olympic Canoeist |
| 2003 |
Jane Sage Cowles '73 |
National Pro Fastpitch Founder |
| 2004 |
Bill Allen '66 |
Sailing |
| 2005 |
James "Jim" Owens '81 |
Cycling |
| 2006 |
Alexandra Keats '80 |
Adventurer |
| 2007 |
Doug Peterson '71 |
Olympic Athlete, Coach and Life-long Athlete |
| 2008 |
Hilary Cairns '88 |
Marathoner, Track Runner, Road Racer and Triathlete |
| 2009 |
Louise Wakefield Otten '65
|
Figure skater, Equestrian |
| 2010 |
Mark Mitchell '83
|
Baseball player |
| 2011 |
Carolyn Moos '97
|
Basketball player |
| 2012 |
Carolyn Lowe Sterrett '82
|
Skier
|